Bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC)
$61,831.00 -3.01%
Bitcoin price
Ethereum
Ethereum (ETH)
$1,748.96 -2.99%
Ethereum price
XRP
XRP (XRP)
$0.960622 -2.02%
XRP price
BNB
BNB (BNB)
$571.78 -3.05%
BNB price
Solana
Solana (SOL)
$71.92 -3.28%
Solana price
Hyperliquid
Hyperliquid (HYPE)
$64.93 -5%
Hyperliquid price
Cardano
Cardano (ADA)
$0.149001 -2.98%
Cardano price
Chainlink
Chainlink (LINK)
$8.84 -3.54%
Chainlink price
POL (ex-MATIC)
POL (ex-MATIC) (POL)
$0.078167 -4.52%
POL (ex-MATIC) price
Gram (prev. Toncoin)
Gram (prev. Toncoin) (GRAM)
$1.02 -1.16%
Gram (prev. Toncoin) price
Pons
Pons (PONS)
$0.103591 -13.06%
Bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC)
$61,831.00 -3.01%
Bitcoin price
Ethereum
Ethereum (ETH)
$1,748.96 -2.99%
Ethereum price
XRP
XRP (XRP)
$0.960622 -2.02%
XRP price
BNB
BNB (BNB)
$571.78 -3.05%
BNB price
Solana
Solana (SOL)
$71.92 -3.28%
Solana price
Hyperliquid
Hyperliquid (HYPE)
$64.93 -5%
Hyperliquid price
Cardano
Cardano (ADA)
$0.149001 -2.98%
Cardano price
Chainlink
Chainlink (LINK)
$8.84 -3.54%
Chainlink price
POL (ex-MATIC)
POL (ex-MATIC) (POL)
$0.078167 -4.52%
POL (ex-MATIC) price
Gram (prev. Toncoin)
Gram (prev. Toncoin) (GRAM)
$1.02 -1.16%
Gram (prev. Toncoin) price
Pons
Pons (PONS)
$0.103591 -13.06%
Bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC)
$61,831.00 -3.01%
Bitcoin price
Ethereum
Ethereum (ETH)
$1,748.96 -2.99%
Ethereum price
XRP
XRP (XRP)
$0.960622 -2.02%
XRP price
BNB
BNB (BNB)
$571.78 -3.05%
BNB price
Solana
Solana (SOL)
$71.92 -3.28%
Solana price
Hyperliquid
Hyperliquid (HYPE)
$64.93 -5%
Hyperliquid price
Cardano
Cardano (ADA)
$0.149001 -2.98%
Cardano price
Chainlink
Chainlink (LINK)
$8.84 -3.54%
Chainlink price
POL (ex-MATIC)
POL (ex-MATIC) (POL)
$0.078167 -4.52%
POL (ex-MATIC) price
Gram (prev. Toncoin)
Gram (prev. Toncoin) (GRAM)
$1.02 -1.16%
Gram (prev. Toncoin) price
Pons
Pons (PONS)
$0.103591 -13.06%
Bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC)
$61,831.00 -3.01%
Bitcoin price
Ethereum
Ethereum (ETH)
$1,748.96 -2.99%
Ethereum price
XRP
XRP (XRP)
$0.960622 -2.02%
XRP price
BNB
BNB (BNB)
$571.78 -3.05%
BNB price
Solana
Solana (SOL)
$71.92 -3.28%
Solana price
Hyperliquid
Hyperliquid (HYPE)
$64.93 -5%
Hyperliquid price
Cardano
Cardano (ADA)
$0.149001 -2.98%
Cardano price
Chainlink
Chainlink (LINK)
$8.84 -3.54%
Chainlink price
POL (ex-MATIC)
POL (ex-MATIC) (POL)
$0.078167 -4.52%
POL (ex-MATIC) price
Gram (prev. Toncoin)
Gram (prev. Toncoin) (GRAM)
$1.02 -1.16%
Gram (prev. Toncoin) price
Pons
Pons (PONS)
$0.103591 -13.06%

Changing a crypto ETF’s custodian involves more than moving coins

Feature
Changing a crypto ETF’s custodian involves more than moving coins

VanEck has given Gemini notice to end custody and clearing agreements for three crypto ETFs in February, while Coinbase remains in place. The handover reaches beyond the location of Bitcoin, Ether and SOL because the funds depend on settlement arrangements, asset reconciliation and, in Solana’s case, a staking service that generates income for shareholders.

Summary
  • VanEck delivered termination notices to Gemini on Nov. 16 and disclosed them in three SEC filings signed on Nov. 19.
  • Gemini’s Bitcoin and Ethereum agreements end on or about Feb. 16, 2027, while the Solana filing specifies that date without qualification.
  • Coinbase Custody will continue serving all three funds under existing agreements, so the notices do not describe the appointment of a new provider.
  • The Solana fund’s Gemini staking addendum terminates, leaving the replacement arrangement undisclosed in the notice despite $663,504 in nine-month staking income.
  • A fund’s holdings, the amount allocated to each custodian and the volume requiring an on-chain transfer are three different measurements.

VanEck’s decision to end its relationship with Gemini gives investors an unusually clear date for a change that often happens outside their view. Written notices delivered on Nov. 16 start the process of ending custody and clearing agreements used by its Bitcoin, Ethereum and Solana ETFs.

The three-fund custody change was disclosed in filings signed on Nov. 19. Gemini continues providing services until the agreements end in February 2027, and Coinbase Custody remains a provider across the products.

The notices do not identify a loss of assets, a completed transfer or a forced sale of the funds’ holdings. They set out the end of contractual relationships that cover safekeeping, cash accounts and the settlement of certain trades.

Solana adds another responsibility to the handover. Gemini facilitates staking for VanEck’s SOL fund, and the agreement supporting that work ends with custody, leaving a source of shareholder income to be addressed alongside control of the coins.

The notices start a handover, rather than document its completion

VanEck’s Bitcoin termination filing identifies custody and clearing agreements dating to October 2023. The Ethereum termination filing covers custody agreed in May 2024 and a separate clearing agreement from that month.

Both say termination takes effect on or about Feb. 16, 2027. The Solana termination notice, covering its June 2025 custody agreement and a May 2024 clearing agreement, gives Feb. 16 without the same qualification.

From Nov. 16 to Feb. 16 is 92 calendar days. That interval provides a period in which the existing contracts continue while VanEck prepares for their termination.

The difference between notice and completion affects how an observer should interpret subsequent blockchain activity. A transfer in December could form part of preparation, while a quiet day immediately after disclosure would not show that the handover had failed to begin.

The Bitcoin filing says Gemini “will continue to provide services to the Trust” until the termination takes effect. The same continuity is stated in the other notices, giving the parties an operating period before the contracts end.

The agreements remain in force during the interval. A notice to end a service in three months is therefore different from a provider stopping withdrawals or losing access to assets immediately.

The filings do not state why VanEck chose to terminate. Price negotiations, service preferences or other commercial explanations would be speculation unless the parties supply supporting information.

No replacement custodian is being introduced in these notices. Coinbase already has agreements with the funds, making the disclosed continuity different from an initial appointment requiring an entirely new relationship.

Existing contracts can simplify a transition because the continuing provider already has a defined role. They do not establish that every operational function supplied by the departing provider has automatically been replicated.

The Solana staking addendum demonstrates the distinction. The filing expressly says it terminates with Gemini’s custody agreement, while saying only that Coinbase continues as a SOL custodian under its additional custody agreement.

Coinbase’s continuing custody role does not establish that it has been appointed to replace Gemini’s staking service. The notice leaves that particular arrangement to be established through further disclosure.

The immediate public record consequently supplies a timetable and identifies continuing custody. It leaves the detailed transfer plan, the commercial rationale and the successor staking setup outside the information disclosed in the notices.

A fund’s asset value is not the size of a wallet transfer

The funds held roughly $1.39 billion in combined net assets at the end of September, according to the figures reported with the notices. The historical total describes the size of the investment products, while the notices leave the allocation between custody providers undisclosed.

The distinction is especially important because Coinbase was already involved. Without a custodian-by-custodian allocation, the full net asset value cannot be assigned to one provider.

A fund can hold receivables, payables and cash as part of its ordinary operations. Net asset value includes those items as well as the market value of its crypto holdings.

VanEck’s Solana fund supplies a concrete example. Its September quarterly accounts show approximately $25.58 million in SOL investments and a $3.17 million receivable for investments sold.

The same balance sheet includes a matching payable for shares redeemed. Adding the receivable to the SOL balance without considering that liability would overstate the net assets available to shareholders.

The accounting distinction matters when a large transfer reaches a blockchain explorer. The visible movement may represent a custody change, a redemption, settlement of a sale or a reorganization within an existing provider’s arrangements.

Identifying the transaction requires more than knowing the fund’s total assets. Wallet attribution, timing, the relevant agreement and an explanation of the transaction’s purpose would support a firmer conclusion.

A transfer to another custody address does not by itself show a sale on an exchange. The beneficial owner can remain the same while the party responsible for safekeeping changes.

Nor does a transfer equal an investor outflow from the ETF. Outflows concern the creation and redemption of fund shares, while custody movements concern how the underlying property is held.

The difference can disappear in a market headline describing coins as leaving a provider. Coins can leave a custody arrangement without leaving the fund, and shares can change hands on an exchange without any underlying coins moving at that moment.

Historical dollar values create another source of confusion. A September valuation uses prices and balances at that reporting date, not the price or quantity that will apply during a February handover.

VanEck’s notices do not supply the information needed to convert the September combined asset total into a February blockchain transfer estimate. Doing so would combine an old balance sheet, an unknown custody allocation and a future implementation plan.

Custody and clearing are different parts of the relationship

The Gemini agreements cover the safekeeping of digital assets and a fiat account for cash. They provide clearing and settlement for purchases and sales between the funds and other Gemini customers.

Ending both services reaches beyond replacing the place where a long-term asset balance is held. A fund needs working procedures for trading, paying expenses and fulfilling the transactions connected with share redemptions.

Custody concerns control and safekeeping. Clearing and settlement concern the completion of transactions, including the point at which obligations between the parties are discharged.

The same company can supply both under different agreements. That is why a short filing can terminate several relationships at once while still using the single familiar name of the service provider.

For the continuing business, the relevant question is which functions remain available under the surviving arrangements. The Bitcoin and Ethereum notices reference Coinbase Prime Broker Agreements, while the Solana notice references an Additional SOL Custody Agreement.

The contract names alone do not justify assuming identical terms across the products. Each fund’s current documents govern what the provider is responsible for and how the work is carried out.

For the Solana fund, share creation and redemption add a further operating cycle. Its quarterly report describes baskets of 25,000 shares available to authorized participants, with cash or SOL used according to the transaction.

Primary-market transactions differ from an investor buying a few shares through a broker. A broker-to-broker trade can change the shareholder without requiring an immediate movement of the corresponding quantity of SOL between custodians.

A custody handover must coexist with the fund’s actual obligations to settle authorized-participant orders. The size and timing of those orders, rather than ordinary exchange share volume alone, help determine which underlying assets need to be available.

The process involves records that do not appear on-chain. The administrator needs holdings that can be reconciled with the custodian’s accounts, while the fund must account for cash, pending settlements, fees and liabilities.

A correct blockchain balance is necessary but insufficient for that complete reconciliation. An unexplained difference in a pending receivable or redemption payable can still affect the calculation of net assets.

For shareholders, the practical expectation is that the fund continues carrying out its investment objective through the handover. A change in service provider should be assessed against that continuing obligation and the actual terms disclosed.

The contracts can allocate responsibilities and exceptions differently, including how instructions are authorized and which costs are borne by the sponsor or trust. A public notice summarizing termination does not reproduce all those provisions.

Reading the relevant agreements therefore matters when a disputed event occurs. The company sending a transfer, the company safeguarding assets and the company calculating NAV may have different responsibilities even though all are involved in the same fund.

The handover is complete only when the responsibilities covered by the ending arrangements have been dealt with, not simply when a blockchain shows the desired quantity at another address. VanEck has not published that completion record in the notices reviewed here.

Solana staking creates a second timetable

VanEck’s SOL fund is designed to reflect the token’s price and the rewards from staking a portion of its holdings, less expenses and subject to the conditions described in its documents. Changing custody therefore touches an income-generating activity as well as safekeeping.

The September report states that Gemini was the only custodian holding staked SOL during the period. Its staking arrangements cannot be treated as an incidental relationship with no connection to the fund’s returns.

The report lists 185,897.32 staked SOL within 215,592.94 SOL held at quarter-end. Dividing those figures gives approximately 86.2% for the quarter-end stake allocation, with subsequent changes requiring a later dated disclosure to establish.

Staking creates timing questions because delegated assets may not be available immediately for every purpose. The report describes an approximately two-to-three-day period of inaccessibility for staked SOL under its arrangements.

The disclosed access period does not mean every custody handover requires a sale or the unstaking of the entire position. The implementation depends on account control, the chosen process and the continuing service arrangements.

The core distinction is between holding an asset and making it immediately available for settlement. A fund can retain ownership while access is constrained by the protocol or the service process used to manage staking.

A liquidity reserve can help meet ordinary obligations without requiring every token to be unstaked at once. Maintaining that reserve means deciding how much of the portfolio remains outside the reward-generating allocation.

A transition plan could therefore affect the balance between liquidity and rewards, even if the fund’s overall SOL exposure remains intact. The notices do not disclose such an allocation decision or estimate its effect.

Shareholders would need the actual staking policy and subsequent reporting to assess whether rewards continued through the handover. The existence of a continuing custodian alone cannot answer that question.

The date a contract terminates differs from the dates on which rewards are earned, recognized, received or distributed. Those events can span different reporting periods.

A reward payment arriving after termination would not necessarily show that the previous contract remained active. It could relate to an entitlement earned earlier, depending on the applicable terms and accounting treatment.

The filing leaves those implementation details open. Its concrete commitment is that Gemini’s staking addendum ends when the custody agreement ends, making the successor service a distinct item for shareholders to follow.

Staking income is not the same as a shareholder’s cash payment

The Solana fund reported $663,504 in net staking income for the first nine months of 2026. Its accounts separately show net investment income of $632,408 after net expenses.

The difference is $31,096, matching the net expense figure in the statement of operations. Calling the full staking-income amount a payment received by shareholders would skip those accounting steps.

The fund records market gains and losses on its SOL exposure. A positive staking-income line can coexist with an overall investment loss because rewards do not remove the risk of a falling token price.

Its nine-month statement illustrates that distinction: investment income is reported alongside realized losses and changes in unrealized appreciation or depreciation. The net result depends on all of them.

The distribution policy introduces another step. The report says staking consideration, net of the staking fee, is intended to be distributed quarterly in cash, with the amount not predictable with certainty.

Converting rewards into cash can involve a sale even where a separate custody transfer does not. A transaction associated with the fund therefore needs its purpose identified before it is described as either routine custody activity or selling pressure.

The report states that cash distributions are not reinvested in additional fund shares. A shareholder’s return consequently depends on distributions as well as changes in the market value of the shares held.

For transition analysis, the right comparison would be rewards earned under the actual allocation before and after the change, adjusted for token amounts, time and applicable fees. Simply annualizing the nine-month dollar figure would ignore changes in the portfolio and SOL price.

An illustrative missed-reward calculation can show the dependency without estimating VanEck’s outcome. If 100,000 SOL were temporarily unproductive for three days at a hypothetical 5% annual reward, the simple forgone amount would be about 41 SOL.

The missed-reward example assumes a constant balance, constant rate and a 365-day year. It says nothing about whether this handover will interrupt staking or whether those inputs resemble the fund’s February position.

The fee terms can matter even when there is no interruption. A different service charge changes the portion of gross rewards available to the fund, while the actual staking participation determines the balance earning them.

A custody announcement supplies neither figure for a successor staking arrangement. Shareholders need those terms before estimating whether the change raises or lowers the net income available for distribution.

Tax status adds conditions to the operating plan

Crypto funds that stake have to consider how their activities fit their tax structure. VanEck’s Solana report describes the trust as a grantor trust, with relevant income, expenses, gains and losses passed through to shareholders.

The IRS addressed that industry problem in updated staking guidance, providing a safe harbor for qualifying investment and grantor trusts. Revenue Procedure 2026-20 clarifies and supersedes the earlier 2025 procedure.

The questions addressed include the use of multiple custodians, liquidity arrangements, slashing protection and the treatment of rewards. That list shows why custody and staking cannot always be reorganized as an isolated wallet operation.

The staking safe-harbor coverage last month concerned the conditions under which a trust can preserve its tax classification. It did not make every staking activity tax-free or declare that every fund automatically satisfies the conditions.

For a sponsor, a service change has to remain compatible with the structure chosen for the product. The commercial advantage of a new arrangement would have limited value if it undermined an essential condition of that structure.

The IRS procedure distinguishes reliance on a safe harbor from every other possible tax question. A favorable rule on trust classification does not answer the tax consequences of each distribution or transaction for every shareholder.

Investors can therefore receive income for tax purposes through a fund even when the fund has a familiar ETF wrapper. The exact consequences depend on the product, the account in which shares are held and the investor’s circumstances.

A custody transition should not be described as a taxable sale merely because assets move between service providers. Determining tax consequences requires the actual transaction and legal ownership, rather than the visual fact of a blockchain transfer.

The same care applies to claims that a new custodian will improve returns. Fees, reward handling, liquidity and tax conditions can interact, leaving the headline custody name insufficient for a complete comparison.

VanEck’s notice makes no announcement about changing the Solana fund’s tax classification. The continuing task is to maintain the disclosed structure while replacing the functions supplied under agreements that are ending.

Responsibility remains with the relevant parties to the fund’s arrangements. Shareholders are not being asked in these filings to move coins themselves, create new wallets or approve an on-chain transaction to preserve their ETF shares.

More providers do not automatically mean less concentration

The institutional custody race has brought banks and specialist companies into competition for digital-asset business. The number of recognizable names can increase while a particular fund remains dependent on a much smaller set of operating relationships.

Adding a second custodian can create an alternative location for assets. Its practical value depends on whether the provider is ready to perform the relevant functions and how much of the portfolio can be moved under the applicable procedures.

Conversely, ending one relationship can reduce the number of providers without demonstrating a deterioration in safekeeping. Contract terms, controls, operational readiness and the distribution of assets determine the actual risk.

The VanEck notices identify Coinbase as continuing across all three products. They do not provide a quantified assessment of the concentration that will result or state that a previously diversified allocation will become a single-wallet arrangement.

The September Solana report discloses another relationship: VanEck held less than 1% of the equity in Gemini’s parent company. The termination notice does not say whether that investment changed or connect it to the decision to end the service agreements.

An equity interest in a provider and a custody contract are separate relationships. Ending the contract does not, on its own, announce a sale of the investment or establish a disagreement between the parties.

The disclosure is relevant because readers evaluating commercial relationships need to know which connections are stated in the record. It supplies context for the relationship while leaving the reason for termination undisclosed.

The same report identifies other related-party connections, including the sponsor and the benchmark administrator. The disclosures identify the connections behind the operating structure, helping investors assess the relationships between the sponsor, service providers and trading counterparties.

An institution can segregate assets in several ways within one custody relationship. Multiple addresses, separate accounts and the identity of the legal custodian are different dimensions of that arrangement.

Counting addresses is therefore a poor substitute for reading the contracts. One provider may control many addresses, while one address can be part of a structure requiring approvals from multiple parties.

The SEC custody proposal discussed in October raises a related question about who verifies controls when certain funds hold their own keys. Its proposed framework should not be mistaken for an already applicable exemption governing every crypto ETF.

Ownership, control and verification remain separate responsibilities. An investor owns fund shares, the trust holds the underlying assets and service providers perform defined functions on the trust’s behalf.

A change in one provider must be assessed through those relationships. A provider’s brand or the number of providers listed does not independently establish how instructions are approved, balances checked or disputed losses allocated.

For the public, updated agreements and financial statements provide more useful evidence than speculation about unlabeled wallets. They can identify who is responsible after the termination date and whether the promised continuity has been achieved.

The notices do not announce a reduction in shareholder protection or an increase in it. They announce a commercial change whose effects depend on the arrangements in place when the existing agreements end.

The next disclosures will show what continued through February

The immediate deadline is contractual, but investors will encounter the result through trading, NAV and distributions. Those ordinary functions offer a way to assess continuity without assuming that every operational step will be public.

NAV calculations need to incorporate the correct holdings and liabilities throughout the process. A transfer does not change the token’s market price, although fees, expenses or a change in productive staking allocation could affect the fund’s net result.

The costs of ETF ownership extend beyond the identity of the custodian. Comparing the fund with its stated benchmark and accounting for distributions gives shareholders a better basis for evaluating their result.

Tracking difference and tracking error should still be kept separate. The first concerns the return gap against a benchmark, while the second concerns how variable that gap is over time.

An unusual return gap around a handover would warrant examining the fund’s holdings, income and expenses over the relevant dates. Market timing, cash balances, rewards and ordinary expenses can influence the comparison.

The Solana fund’s distribution record will help show what happened to staking income. A successor agreement would add the details needed to understand who supplies the service and which fees and responsibilities apply.

For Bitcoin and Ethereum, further disclosures may clarify whether any operational arrangements changed alongside the ending contracts. Their notices already identify continuing custody, but do not describe every settlement procedure that will be used afterward.

No filing reviewed here announces that the funds must liquidate their underlying assets because Gemini’s contracts are ending. A custody transfer and an asset sale remain different events unless a disclosed implementation connects them.

The next quarterly accounts can help reconcile the reported balances with the handover period. They will provide dated financial positions against which the implementation can be assessed, including changes since the September figures now available.

Until that information arrives, the clearest outstanding question concerns the service explicitly scheduled to end alongside SOL custody. VanEck’s notice identifies Gemini’s staking addendum, gives its termination date and does not name the agreement that will replace it.

What to Watch

  • Termination dates: Confirmation of the Feb. 16 handover, including any update to the “on or about” wording in the Bitcoin and Ethereum notices.
  • Staking successor: The provider, agreement and fee terms replacing Gemini’s SOL staking addendum, which the current termination filing does not identify.
  • Asset reconciliation: Updated financial statements distinguishing total fund holdings, liabilities and any disclosed allocation between custody providers during the transition.
  • Income continuity: Staking participation, rewards recognized, fees and cash distributions over the handover period, assessed against matching reporting dates.
  • Operating disclosures: Any changes to settlement arrangements, liquidity policies or extraordinary expenses that shareholders need to understand before the contracts end.

FAQs

Is VanEck moving all $1.39 billion out of Gemini?

The combined figure describes historical fund net assets at the end of September. It does not disclose how much each custodian held or the quantity that needs to move on-chain. A precise transfer amount requires a dated custody allocation and an implementation plan.

Does the decision mean the funds will sell their crypto?

The termination notices do not announce a forced liquidation of Bitcoin, Ether or SOL. Assets can change custody while remaining owned by the same fund. Any sale would need to be identified separately from a transfer for safekeeping.

Will Gemini stop servicing the funds immediately?

The filings say its agreements and services continue until the termination dates. Bitcoin and Ethereum use “on or about” Feb. 16, 2027, while Solana specifies that date. The notice period is therefore a transition interval rather than an immediate withdrawal of service.

Is Coinbase a new custodian for these funds?

Coinbase already has agreements with the products and will continue in its custody role. The notices do not describe a first appointment. Existing custody continuity should still be distinguished from any separate decision about clearing or staking services.

Why is the Solana fund different?

Gemini facilitates SOL staking under an addendum that ends with its custody agreement. The fund earned staking income and identified Gemini as its only custodian holding staked SOL during the September reporting period. Replacing that function consequently matters alongside the safekeeping of the underlying assets.

Does $663,504 represent cash distributed to shareholders?

The $663,504 figure is net staking income reported for the first nine months of 2026. The accounts separately identify expenses, net investment income and a policy for quarterly cash distributions. Those are related figures and events, but they are not interchangeable.

Does changing custody create a taxable sale?

A transfer between service providers does not by itself establish that beneficial ownership changed or that an asset was sold. Tax treatment depends on the actual transaction and the fund’s legal structure. Staking, reward sales and shareholder distributions can raise separate questions.

Which disclosure matters most before February?

For the SOL fund, a successor staking arrangement would resolve an important gap left by the termination notice. Updated contracts, financial statements and distribution reporting would then show how operations continued through the change. This is educational analysis, not investment advice.

Disclaimer: This article is for information and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Figures reflect regulatory filings and reporting available at the time of writing and change with each disclosure. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or asset. Always do your own research. Information is accurate as of Nov. 20, 2026. Legal and tax questions should be discussed with qualified professionals.